Paul Klee - Hände hoch! (Centre Pompidou, Paris)
May 4-7, 2014
Didier Fassin, Organizer
In the past half century, there has been a considerable amount of scientific literature in criminology, sociology, political science and legal studies on urban policing, that is, on the practice of law enforcement mostly in the poor neighborhoods of large cities. Part of this work is grounded on some form of participant observation, which complements other techniques such as interviews or questionnaires, and nourishes the analytical and theoretical arguments developed by the authors. However, this ethnography rarely appears as such. It is usually not presented, save occasionally in the form of short vignettes, or discussed, from the perspective of the specific contribution of this method. Significantly, until recently, anthropologists themselves seemed to ignore policing practices. In the past decade, this situation has begun to change, as scholars explicitly include ethnographic elements in their study of police work.
The objective of the workshop is to bring together social scientists who have conducted research on urban policing in different parts of the world, using ethnography, in order to collectively reflect on the conditions, potentialities and limits of this method, the problems of interpretation and the ethical issues it raises, and the way local findings can be related to larger historical context and sociological issues. The general idea is to take ethnography seriously rather than as a mere background rendered invisible in the process of writing. Considering the importance of public debates on policing in contemporary societies, particularly on the way law is enforced in poor neighborhoods, which raises questions about racial discrimination, display of violence, and reproduction of an unequal social order, the exchange of ethnographic experiences will be illuminating. The outcome of this workshop will be a collective volume.
Elif Babül (Mount Holyoke College, on Turkey)
Susana Durão (University of Campinas, on Portugal)
Didier Fassin (Institute for Advanced Study, on France)
Daniel Goldstein (Rutgers University, on Bolivia)
Clara Han (The Johns Hopkins University, on Chile)
Steven Herbert (University of Washington, on the United States)
Julia Hornberger (University of the Witwatersrand, on South Africa)
Beatrice Jauregui (University of Pennsylvania, on India)
Helene Maria Kyed (Danish Institute for International Studies, on Mozambique)
Jeffrey Martin (University of Hong Kong, on Taiwan)
Duncan McCargo (University of Leeds, on Thailand)